Please see attached letter which is being sent to Pope Francis in the next several days:
January 20, 2019
His Holiness, Pope Frances
The Apostolic Palace
00120 Vatican City
I am writing to you today to voice some deep concerns over the state of the Catholic Church in the United States. I decided to write this letter after witnessing the despicable behavior of some Covington Catholic high school boys as they harassed a Native American while attending a March for Life event in Washington, D.C. These boys were wearing MAGA hats and t-shirts, so they clearly support Donald Trump.
I have been a Catholic my whole life. I attended St. Gertrude school in Madeira, Ohio which is a suburb of Cincinnati. Covington is just over the river from Cincinnati, and it is rightly considered a suburb of Cincinnati even though it is in a different archdiocese. The Cincinnati airport is located in Covington, and many people who live in Covington work in Cincinnati. There are even families that live in Cincinnati that send their kids to schools in Covington. So, as you can see, the two areas interact quite a bit, so it is appropriate to address the archdiocese of Cincinnati along with the archdiocese of Covington when addressing this issue since they are in the same general area.
I no longer live in Cincinnati as I have moved due to work. However, I still have a lot of family and friends that live there. Many are wonderful people who I love very much and who in no way condone the actions of the Covington high school boys. However, there are quite a few Catholics who are die-hard supporters of Donald Trump and who are very hateful.
I have lived in 5 states – Ohio, Kentucky, South Carolina, Texas and Virginia. I have friends all over the United States from all walks of life. I am embarrassed to say that the most hateful rhetoric is coming from people in the Cincinnati area. I was disgusted to read what happened with those high school boys, but sadly I was not too surprised based on the pure hate of Democrats and the adoration of Trump from some of the Catholics that I know in that area.
I posted the video of the boys taunting the Native American man on Facebook, and some of those from Cincinnati took me on. They tried to say that they were just young and “made a mistake”. Others tried to say that it was the archdiocese of Covington, not Cincinnati as they tried to distance themselves from the incident. One guy named John ******** stated that he was a Catholic teacher in the archdiocese of Cincinnati. When I explained to him that the hate needed to stop…that these kids weren’t born with hate in their hearts and that their behavior was a reflection of what the adults around them were doing/saying regarding support of Donald Trump…he posted a cartoon gif of a man beating a dead horse. Clearly, this Catholic teacher didn’t care, and he was making a joke out of a very serious issue.
This morning, I checked Twitter and found a post from a Catholic priest named Fr. Frank Pavone who was at the March for Life rally. He was complaining about the caravan that was forming in Honduras and clearly stated that he supported Donald Trump and called Democrats “un-American”. I have attached a copy of it for your review.
Another instance that I would like to mention is one when a Catholic priest told his parishioners in a church in the western U.S. that it would be a “mortal sin” to vote Democrat in the 2016 election due to the abortion issue.
I feel the Catholic church is veering off the right path. Catholics here in the U.S., especially those who I hear from in Cincinnati, have become laser-focused on the abortion issue. Yes, clearly abortion is a very important issue, and I am very much pro-life. But at what point do we become so laser-focused on that one issue that we end up ignoring all other sin? Well, I think that day is here in the U.S. Many Catholics here believe that all Democrats are evil, and they wouldn’t dare vote for one even if the Republican candidate is Donald Trump who is probably the most corrupt and sinful man to ever occupy the Oval Office.
I read this passage this morning, and it hit a nerve with me. I hope you will see that the abortion issue has become so important in Catholicism that other sin is being neglected.
“Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! For you tithe mint, dill, and cumin, and have neglected the weightier matters of the law: justice and mercy and faith. IT IS THESE YOU OUGHT TO HAVE PRACTICED WITHOUT NEGLECTING THE OTHERS. You blind guides! You strain out a gnat but swallow a camel!” Matthew 23:23-24
Catholics need to remember that they can be pro-life, but they must not ignore other sin while doing so. Not all Republicans in the U.S. are good people, and it is imperative that Catholics stand up against a Republican if he/she is doing the wrong thing according to scripture. I am sickened by the Catholic support of Donald Trump. He lies pretty much every single day, and he calls people names constantly. All you have to do is look at his Twitter feed. Yet some Catholics here follow him as if he is almost a prophet…not all Catholics, but there are certainly some here who do this (along with other evangelical Christians), and I strongly believe this is what led to the despicable actions of those high school boys. I can’t tell you the number of times that I have heard that “God put Trump in office”. And it is all based on that single fact – that Donald Trump claims he is pro-life.
I am asking you, Your Holiness, to direct the misled Catholics back onto the right track. Please remind them that abortion is not the only sin, and that we, as Catholics, should never, ever condone sin of any kind even if it comes from a Republican. Also, a priest should never, ever say that it is a mortal sin to vote Democrat. The Church is already dealing with the abuse crisis, and now we are facing this. Please help us. Thank you.
Cc: Archdiocese of Cincinnati, Archdiocese of Covington
Honest to God, I am really getting sick and tired of these caravans. What in the world is this? Just come and push your way into the country? And all of this just happening by itself? Thank you, @realDonaldTrump for standing firm against the un-American #Democrat party. #MAGA